Dental restoration / Published data reanalysis
See the source-derived curve summaries
Dental bulk resistance and host attachment need separate measurements
Listed traces and serial points do not identify independent specimens. Bulk response and the separate delamination traces do not link actual repair thickness to host-interface fatigue or clinical durability.
{
"data_kind": "descriptive_observed_bulk_material_comparator",
"full_repair_depth_interface_durability_eligible": false,
"fatigue_trace_summaries": [
{
"material": "enamel",
"trace_identity": "Fig.4c:D",
"n_serial_points": 159,
"n_listed_traces": 1,
"independent_specimen_or_donor_n": null,
"observed_cycle_window": [
100.0,
150000.0
],
"first_source_displacement_mm": 0.02033,
"last_source_displacement_mm": 0.20008,
"change_over_observed_window_mm": 0.17975000000000002,
"cycle_weighted_mean_displacement_mm": 0.18446529019346228,
"decreasing_displacement_steps_retained": 31,
"failure_time_or_survival_probability": null
},
{
"material": "HEA",
"trace_identity": "Fig.4c:E",
"n_serial_points": 159,
"n_listed_traces": 1,
"independent_specimen_or_donor_n": null,
"observed_cycle_window": [
100.0,
150000.0
],
"first_source_displacement_mm": 0.0183,
"last_source_displacement_mm": 0.17356,
"change_over_observed_window_mm": 0.15525999999999998,
"cycle_weighted_mean_displacement_mm": 0.07802185123415609,
"decreasing_displacement_steps_retained": 15,
"failure_time_or_survival_probability": null
},
{
"material": "EA",
"trace_identity": "Fig.4c:F",
"n_serial_points": 159,
"n_listed_traces": 1,
"independent_specimen_or_donor_n": null,
"observed_cycle_window": [
100.0,
150000.0
],
"first_source_displacement_mm": 0.01886,
"last_source_displacement_mm": 0.30076,
"change_over_observed_window_mm": 0.28190000000000004,
"cycle_weighted_mean_displacement_mm": 0.16303742161440962,
"decreasing_displacement_steps_retained": 2,
"failure_time_or_survival_probability": null
}
],
"main_bulk_R_curve_comparison": {
"common_observed_crack_extension_mm": [
0.0,
0.0784
],
"interpolation": "piecewise linear within observed coordinates only",
"traces": [
{
"trace_identity": "Fig.6b:C:D",
"material": "HEA",
"architecture_context": "main_perpendicular",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 3.6376,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.19795,
"last_source_K": 19.79316,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 14.001304642857143,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 9.348969871196246,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
},
{
"trace_identity": "Fig.6b:E:F",
"material": "HEA",
"architecture_context": "main_perpendicular",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 3.68273,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.19317,
"last_source_K": 19.60513,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 14.266355036524415,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 9.864778719575575,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
},
{
"trace_identity": "Fig.6b:G:H",
"material": "enamel",
"architecture_context": "main_perpendicular",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 0.96386,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.08586,
"last_source_K": 5.90496,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 5.644793293617021,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 4.2217513522297,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
},
{
"trace_identity": "Fig.6b:I:J",
"material": "enamel",
"architecture_context": "main_perpendicular",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 0.84386,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.0784,
"last_source_K": 5.44496,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 5.44496,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 3.9436790242346937,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
},
{
"trace_identity": "Fig.6b:K:L",
"material": "EA",
"architecture_context": "main_perpendicular",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 2.33395,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.13068,
"last_source_K": 10.1824,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 8.475703770491803,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 6.008578940709684,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
},
{
"trace_identity": "Fig.6b:M:N",
"material": "EA",
"architecture_context": "main_perpendicular",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 2.05523,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.13391,
"last_source_K": 10.21752,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 6.947232321428571,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 4.965265783516307,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
}
],
"trace_summaries": [
{
"material": "HEA",
"architecture_context": "main_perpendicular",
"n_listed_traces": 2,
"trace_mean_K_at_common_upper": 14.13382983969078,
"trace_range_K_at_common_upper": [
14.001304642857143,
14.266355036524415
],
"trace_mean_of_interval_mean_K": 9.60687429538591,
"independent_specimen_or_donor_n": null,
"new_sem_or_confidence_interval": null
},
{
"material": "enamel",
"architecture_context": "main_perpendicular",
"n_listed_traces": 2,
"trace_mean_K_at_common_upper": 5.544876646808511,
"trace_range_K_at_common_upper": [
5.44496,
5.644793293617021
],
"trace_mean_of_interval_mean_K": 4.082715188232196,
"independent_specimen_or_donor_n": null,
"new_sem_or_confidence_interval": null
},
{
"material": "EA",
"architecture_context": "main_perpendicular",
"n_listed_traces": 2,
"trace_mean_K_at_common_upper": 7.711468045960187,
"trace_range_K_at_common_upper": [
6.947232321428571,
8.475703770491803
],
"trace_mean_of_interval_mean_K": 5.486922362112995,
"independent_specimen_or_donor_n": null,
"new_sem_or_confidence_interval": null
}
]
},
"source_label_directional_R_curve_comparison": {
"common_observed_crack_extension_mm": [
0.0,
0.04577
],
"interpolation": "piecewise linear within observed coordinates only",
"traces": [
{
"trace_identity": "Supplementary Fig. 43c:E:F",
"material": "HEA",
"architecture_context": "source_LD",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 1.06703,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.09982,
"last_source_K": 7.30237,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 4.150231446229913,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 2.7444430049357336,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
},
{
"trace_identity": "Supplementary Fig. 43c:H:I",
"material": "HEA",
"architecture_context": "source_LD",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 1.37276,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.09858,
"last_source_K": 7.21046,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 4.043903786644951,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 2.740046830946084,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
},
{
"trace_identity": "Supplementary Fig. 43c:K:L",
"material": "enamel",
"architecture_context": "source_LD",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 0.31851,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.05417,
"last_source_K": 2.3536,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 1.9050517161716172,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 1.3669076069831148,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
},
{
"trace_identity": "Supplementary Fig. 43c:N:O",
"material": "enamel",
"architecture_context": "source_LD",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 0.26437,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.0522,
"last_source_K": 2.23938,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 2.0417148484848484,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 1.2970545465867644,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
},
{
"trace_identity": "Supplementary Fig. 43f:E:F",
"material": "HEA",
"architecture_context": "source_TD",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 1.66901,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.14953,
"last_source_K": 11.17304,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 4.3205896955503515,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 3.1060326514841794,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
},
{
"trace_identity": "Supplementary Fig. 43f:H:I",
"material": "HEA",
"architecture_context": "source_TD",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 1.51664,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.1419,
"last_source_K": 10.72061,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 4.436700732265446,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 3.02640561515667,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
},
{
"trace_identity": "Supplementary Fig. 43f:K:L",
"material": "enamel",
"architecture_context": "source_TD",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 0.63914,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.04577,
"last_source_K": 4.09311,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 4.09311,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 2.560248443303474,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
},
{
"trace_identity": "Supplementary Fig. 43f:N:O",
"material": "enamel",
"architecture_context": "source_TD",
"n_serial_points": 11,
"initial_source_K": 0.52874,
"last_source_crack_extension_mm": 0.0474,
"last_source_K": 4.17876,
"K_at_common_upper_MPa_sqrt_m": 4.024409108527132,
"mean_K_over_common_interval_MPa_sqrt_m": 2.196932573225921,
"decreasing_K_steps_retained": 0
}
],
"trace_summaries": [
{
"material": "HEA",
"architecture_context": "source_LD",
"n_listed_traces": 2,
"trace_mean_K_at_common_upper": 4.097067616437432,
"trace_range_K_at_common_upper": [
4.043903786644951,
4.150231446229913
],
"trace_mean_of_interval_mean_K": 2.7422449179409085,
"independent_specimen_or_donor_n": null,
"new_sem_or_confidence_interval": null
},
{
"material": "enamel",
"architecture_context": "source_LD",
"n_listed_traces": 2,
"trace_mean_K_at_common_upper": 1.973383282328233,
"trace_range_K_at_common_upper": [
1.9050517161716172,
2.0417148484848484
],
"trace_mean_of_interval_mean_K": 1.3319810767849396,
"independent_specimen_or_donor_n": null,
"new_sem_or_confidence_interval": null
},
{
"material": "HEA",
"architecture_context": "source_TD",
"n_listed_traces": 2,
"trace_mean_K_at_common_upper": 4.378645213907898,
"trace_range_K_at_common_upper": [
4.3205896955503515,
4.436700732265446
],
"trace_mean_of_interval_mean_K": 3.0662191333204247,
"independent_specimen_or_donor_n": null,
"new_sem_or_confidence_interval": null
},
{
"material": "enamel",
"architecture_context": "source_TD",
"n_listed_traces": 2,
"trace_mean_K_at_common_upper": 4.058759554263566,
"trace_range_K_at_common_upper": [
4.024409108527132,
4.09311
],
"trace_mean_of_interval_mean_K": 2.3785905082646974,
"independent_specimen_or_donor_n": null,
"new_sem_or_confidence_interval": null
}
]
},
"roughness_summary_changes": [
{
"material": "HEA",
"before_mean_nm": 3.35,
"after_mean_nm": 4.13,
"source_before_sd_nm": 0.25,
"source_after_sd_nm": 0.36,
"difference_of_reported_means_nm": 0.7799999999999998,
"relative_change_of_reported_means_percent": 23.283582089552233,
"paired_individual_change_variance_or_CI": null,
"interpretation": "Unfavorable roughness direction retained; a difference of published means is not a paired specimen-level estimate or equivalence test"
},
{
"material": "enamel",
"before_mean_nm": 3.27,
"after_mean_nm": 4.08,
"source_before_sd_nm": 0.22,
"source_after_sd_nm": 0.35,
"difference_of_reported_means_nm": 0.81,
"relative_change_of_reported_means_percent": 24.770642201834868,
"paired_individual_change_variance_or_CI": null,
"interpretation": "Unfavorable roughness direction retained; a difference of published means is not a paired specimen-level estimate or equivalence test"
},
{
"material": "EA",
"before_mean_nm": 3.41,
"after_mean_nm": 12.14,
"source_before_sd_nm": 0.28,
"source_after_sd_nm": 1.14,
"difference_of_reported_means_nm": 8.73,
"relative_change_of_reported_means_percent": 256.0117302052786,
"paired_individual_change_variance_or_CI": null,
"interpretation": "Unfavorable roughness direction retained; a difference of published means is not a paired specimen-level estimate or equivalence test"
}
],
"published_toughness_summaries_kept_separate": [
{
"material": "HEA",
"source_sheet": "Supplementary Fig. 41",
"KIC_mean": 3.79,
"KIC_source_sd": 0.55,
"KJC_mean": 19.8,
"KJC_source_sd": 2.9,
"cells": [
"E4",
"F4",
"G4",
"H4"
],
"raw_specimen_crosswalk": null
},
{
"material": "enamel",
"source_sheet": "Supplementary Fig. 41",
"KIC_mean": 0.96,
"KIC_source_sd": 0.41,
"KJC_mean": 5.9,
"KJC_source_sd": 0.98,
"cells": [
"I4",
"J4",
"K4",
"L4"
],
"raw_specimen_crosswalk": null
},
{
"material": "EA",
"source_sheet": "Supplementary Fig. 41",
"KIC_mean": 2.34,
"KIC_source_sd": 0.33,
"KJC_mean": 10.1,
"KJC_source_sd": 1.1,
"cells": [
"M4",
"N4",
"O4",
"P4"
],
"raw_specimen_crosswalk": null
}
],
"host_enamel_delamination_source_ordinate_comparison": {
"traces": [
{
"material": "HEA",
"trace_identity": "Supplementary Fig. 8:C:D",
"n_serial_points": 298,
"peak_source_stress_ordinate": 63.39339,
"source_displacement_at_peak": 0.41386,
"absolute_stress_unit_validated": null,
"independent_specimen_or_donor_n": null
},
{
"material": "ZrO2",
"trace_identity": "Supplementary Fig. 8:E:F",
"n_serial_points": 193,
"peak_source_stress_ordinate": 18.50492,
"source_displacement_at_peak": 0.40667,
"absolute_stress_unit_validated": null,
"independent_specimen_or_donor_n": null
}
],
"peak_ordinate_ratio_HEA_to_ZrO2": 3.425758663101489,
"ratio_qualification": "Conditional on the common stress ordinate scale used for the two traces in the same source figure. Identical stress headers and primary delamination-comparison text support that reading; absolute units, actual bond areas and per-specimen geometry are not validated. This is a ratio of two listed trace peaks, not a cohort mean or validated absolute bond strength.",
"host_interface_fatigue_or_repair_depth_linkage": null
},
"source_summary_reconstruction_from_two_curves_attempted": false,
"interface_assay_audit": {
"sheet": "Supplementary Fig. 48",
"header_F1": "displacement(mm)",
"header_G1": "force(N)",
"source_context": "Primary methods explicitly link Supplementary Fig.48 to corroboration of compliance and crack length in SENB calculations",
"is_host_enamel_shear_bond_dataset": false,
"numeric_force_curve_not_used_as_interface_data": true,
"identified_host_bond_numeric_table": "Supplementary Fig. 8",
"actual_interface_context": "Primary results explicitly associate Supplementary Fig.8 with delamination of HEA or ZrO2 from enamel",
"absolute_ordinate_unit_and_area_validated": false
},
"hierarchy_and_missingness": {
"serial_R_curve_points": 154,
"serial_fatigue_points": 477,
"listed_R_curves": 14,
"listed_fatigue_traces": 3,
"listed_interface_traces": 2,
"serial_interface_points": 491,
"donor_count": null,
"independent_specimen_count_from_deposited_vectors": null,
"per_specimen_measured_repair_thickness": null,
"per_specimen_geometry_to_curve_crosswalk": null,
"joint_host_interface_fatigue_or_leakage": null,
"native_PDL_gum_pulp_and_pose_after_finite_support": null
},
"calendar_life_or_growth_forecast": null,
"uncertainty_qualification": "Trace ranges and missing source linkage are not confidence intervals. Processed source R-curves are not revalidated toughness measurements. Geometry/orientation, source summary SD hierarchy and absent donor/specimen identifiers limit transfer to repaired teeth.",
"inputs_text_sha256": "7a4c299545b0fed66e7f3b29f95abc93374c7cdb334f54b39640900ab2f8d229"
}